Rescue by Anita Shreve (audiobook)

Anita Shreve is one of my all-time favorite authors. I have read every one of her novels. This is my first time listening to one of her books instead of reading it the old-fashioned way. I enjoy audiobooks and it was interesting to determine whether a Shreve novel would translate well to an audiobook.

Rescue is a novel that encompasses many of Shreve’s themes throughout the portfolio of her work. Sheila Arsenault is a woman on the run from an abusive relationship. After crashing her car in an alcohol fueled incident, Sheila is rescued by rookie paramedic Peter Webster. Webster is taken by the beautiful young victim and searches her out after she is discharged from the hospital. Webster is determined to help her and falls in love along the way. Sheila is happy to be rescued, but finds that old demons are hard to leave behind.
Eighteen years later, Webster is raising their daughter, Rowan alone. Rowan unfortunately seems to have inherited some dangerous addictions and traits from her mother. Will Webster be able to save his daughter or is it already too late?

I enjoyed listening to this audiobook. Dennis Holland did a fairly good reading of the novel, although I found his attempts at a Boston accent to be rather jarring. I almost wanted to do the dishes every day so I could listen to what was going to happen next. I found the plot to be compelling, but the best thing about the novel was the in depth character studies. Rash decisions that were made in youth can lead to consequences that can last a life time.

I also found Webster’s job as a paramedic to be very interesting as were the stories of his rescues. I’ve never read a book with a paramedic as the main character and I really enjoyed it. It left me wanting to know even more about the profession. I think it was a great way to talk about how Webster rescued people as his job in life, but that he had troubles at home with rescuing his wife and his daughter. It’s not as easy to rescue those you love from addictions and bad behavior.

Anita Shreve is a gifted writer. I love her style of writing. That being said, while Rescue was a good book, I still hold some of her earlier works such as The Weight of Water and Fortune’s Rocks in much higher regard. I kind of miss her historical books!

Overall, Rescue was a compelling story with great characters that I enjoyed listening too.

This is my first item for the Audiobook Challenge 2011.

Audiobook Source: Review copy from Hachette Book Group. Thank-you!

Winners of Cleopatra by Stacy Schiff

I apologize for posting the two winners of the audiobook version of Cleopatra by Stacy Schiff so late. I was out of town this past weekend for my sister's baby shower and returned to a boat load of work that was due for a meeting on Wednesday. When Wednesday arrived, not one, not two, but all three of my kids came down with a nasty flu bug that included high fevers and other nasty flu side effects. Two out of the three are still sick today, but I think we've turned a corner. I'm just happy to get to my computer a bit of "me" time!

There was a lot of interest in this book, but unfortunately, there can only be two winners. And the two winners of Cleopatra by Stacy Schiff are Esme of Chocolate and Croissants and Nichole. Both winners were chosen using random.org and were notified via email. They have until next Thursday, February 3rd to send me their mailing addresses. If I do not hear from them, new winners will be chosen.

Thank-you to Anna from Hachette Book Group for allowing me to host this great giveaway! Thank-you to all who entered this giveaway! I still have one giveaway currently on my sidebar (The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy) and have a couple more that will be posted this next week so stay tuned!

I am currently listening to the audiobook of Cleopatra by Stacy Schiff and am enjoying it greatly. If you didn't win this book, I highly recommend picking it up!

Interview (and GIVEAWAY) with Mary Lydon Simonsen, author of The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy

Mary Lydon Simonsen is a guest today on Laura's Reviews. Her new novel, The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy, " is the perfect book for all lovers of Pride and Prejudice to fill in the behind the scenes details of how our favorite two lovers were finally able to get together." See my review from earlier this week for more of my thoughts on this novel. Mary Lydon Simonsen graciously agreed to answer my burning questions about this novel.

LAG: What was your inspiration for making Georgiana Darcy and Anne de Bourgh into match makers? It is a unique and fresh twist to the Pride and Prejudice story.

MLS: When I first read Pride and Prejudice, I was just about Georgiana’s age, and I wanted to know more about her. I wondered if she was able to get over her near elopement with the dastardly George Wickham. Little did I know that I would answer my own question when I wrote a novel 40 years later. As for Anne De Bourgh, I always felt she drew the short straw in Pride and Prejudice. Wasn’t it enough that she had Lady Catherine as a mother without making her “sickly and cross?” I wanted to rehabilitate her character, and so I made her a matchmaker for Darcy and Elizabeth. She later enlists Georgiana and Colonel Fitzwilliam’s help in bringing our favorite couple together at Pemberley. (LAG - I have to admit I laughed out loud at your answer, "Wasn’t it enough that she had Lady Catherine as a mother without making her 'sickly and cross?'”)

LAG: Why did you decide to make the Bingleys only three of a large family of nine? I like the new Bingley siblings.

MLS: Charles is a bit wishy-washy for my taste, and with all that money, I thought he needed guidance from an older sibling. While George Bingley, the eldest brother, watches the store, Charles tries to mend fences with Jane Bennet, and in pursuing Jane, he becomes a better, more mature man and one who is less dependent upon Mr. Darcy. But while these changes were taking place, Jane permitted a certain Mr. Nesbitt to call. Everyone knows a Mr. Nesbitt type—someone whom I refer to as a conversation killer.

LAG: When did you first discover Jane Austen and what do you love about her novels?

MLS: I first met Jane Austen in high school. Pride and Prejudice was required reading in my English class, and I loved Austen’s novel so much that I read everything else she wrote in a reading marathon. I was particularly drawn to Elizabeth Bennet and Anne Elliot. I was like the shy Anne Elliot, but I wanted to become the spunky Elizabeth Bennet. And who wouldn’t want to end up with Captain Wentworth or Mr. Darcy?

LAG: I see in your author biography that you wrote a book called “Anne Elliot, A New Beginning.” I love Anne Elliot! Persuasion is tied with Pride and Prejudice as my favorite Austen novel. Can you tell us about this novel?

MLS: Me too! I love Persuasion and Pride and Prejudice equally. I will gladly tell you about my self-published novel, but first a word of warning. Anne Elliot, A New Beginning is a parody of Persuasion. Because I wanted to empower Anne, I made her a long-distance runner, and that one change was a catalyst for many others that affects all of the Elliots. In Anne Elliot, our heroine realizes that her cousin, Mr. Elliot, is not an honest person, and so she hires a Bath street urchin to help her trail the heir to the Elliot fortune around town. When Captain Wentworth comes to Bath, he joins in the chase. Although a parody, I was faithful to Austen’s love story. Of all my novels, this was the one I had the most fun writing. Thanks for asking.

LAG: Do you have any future novels in the works that you could tell us about?
MLS: Yes, I do. Sourcebooks is publishing two additional novels. In A Wife for Mr. Darcy, Mr. Darcy goes to Longbourn the day after the assembly to apologize for his rude remarks. This sends their romance down a completely different path. But the course of love never did run smooth. During the season, Mr. Darcy paid sufficient notice to Letitia Montford to get the rumor mill going, and Darcy feels that as a gentleman, he must become engaged to Miss Montford or embarrass the lady. A Wife for Mr. Darcy will be in stores in July 2011. The second novel is quite a departure for me. In Mr. Darcy’s Bite, Mr. Darcy is a werewolf. Fear not fans of our hero, Mr. Darcy retains his humanity, but being a furry creature of the night for two days every month does present complications for our beloved couple. But it’s a howling good tale and will be in stores in October 2011!

LAG: What books are on your shelf? Who do you like to read?

MLS: I read a lot of history, especially about World Wars I and II, Regency England, American history, and coal mining (my ancestors were coal miners). But when I want to read non-fiction, it is usually a mystery. I like Michael Connelly’s Harry Bosch series and Charles Todd and Barbara Cleverly’s post WWI detective series. I am reading an interesting series now: the Julia Grey mysteries by Deanna Raybourn set in the late Victorian Era. Good stuff.

Laura, thank you for having me. This has been a pleasure.

LAG: Thank-you Mary for being a guest. You had great answers to my questions!


THE PERFECT BRIDE FOR MR. DARCY BY MARY LYDON SIMONSEN – IN STORES JANUARY 2011

If the two of them weren’t so stubborn…

It’s obvious to Georgiana Darcy that the lovely Elizabeth Bennet is her brother’s perfect match, but Darcy’s pigheadedness and Elizabeth’s wounded pride are going to keep them both from the loves of their lives.

Georgiana can’t let that happen, so she readily agrees to help her accommodating cousin, Anne de Bourgh, do everything within their power to assure her beloved brother’s happiness.
But the path of matchmaking never runs smoothly…

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mary Lydon Simonsen’s first book, Searching for Pemberley, was acclaimed by Booklist, Publishers Weekly, and RT Book Reviews. She is well loved and widely followed on all the Jane Austen fanfic sites, with tens of thousands of hits and hundreds of reviews whenever she posts. She lives in Peoria, Arizona where she is working on her next Jane Austen novel. For more information, please visit http://marysimonsenfanfiction.blogspot.com/ and http://www.austenauthors.com/, where she regularly contributes.

Giveaway Details
Danielle of Sourcebooks has been kind enough to offer two copies of The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy by Mary Lydon Simonsen for a giveaway.

If you would like to win a copy of The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy, please leave a comment about what intrigues you about the novel or this guest blog.

As part of your comment, you must include an email address. If I can't find a way to contact you I will draw another winner.

For an additional entry, blog about this giveaway or post it on your sidebar. Provide a link to this post in your comment.

I will be using random.org (or a monte carlo simulation in excel) to pick the winners from the comments.

This contest is only open to US and Canadian residents (Sorry!).

No P.O. Boxes.

The deadline for entry is midnight, Friday January 28th.

Good luck!

The Girl in the Green Raincoat by Laura Lippman

The Girl in the Green Raincoat is a thriller reminiscent of Hitchcock’s Rear Window, if the character played by Jimmy Stewart was instead a feisty detective named Tess Monaghan. Tess is heavily pregnant and is on bed rest for preeclampsia. She spends a lot of her time watching out her window and notices a woman in a green raincoat who walks her dog each day. The dog is also dressed in a matching green raincoat. One day the dog runs through the park alone without the woman. When Tess tries to find out the fate of the woman, she discovers that the woman’s husband has had a string of wives who have disappeared mysteriously. Will Tess be able to find the girl in the green raincoat?

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel. It was a quick read and once I started reading it, I couldn’t put it down. The characters are wonderfully developed. Tess is a great character. She is used to standing on her own as a detective and is suddenly depending on others to do the legwork for her. This causes frustration. At the same time she is trying to solve the mystery, she is having concerns about her boyfriend Crow, and about becoming a mother for the first time.

I found Tess to be very relatable as I just had my third child this past October. I was down and out with hypomesis gravidum at the beginning of the pregnancy. It is no fun when you are a hostage of your own body. Her fears and concerns are the same as all women when you are about to become a mother for the first time.

I am a huge Hitchcock fan and I loved the shades of Rear Window in The Girl in the Green Raincoat. The ending of this novel does not disappoint, it is a thriller through and through.
While I have previously read a Laura Lippman novel, it was not one of her Tess Monaghan mystery novels. This novel was great on its own having never read the series. Having said that, I will definitely be checking out the rest of the series!

Lippman’s prose in this novel is exquisite. There were many quotes that were so witty that I laughed out loud. Sadly I didn’t mark my favorite one, but here are a couple of my favorites.

The novel starts out with this quote, “I am being held hostage,” Tess Monaghan whispered into her iPhone. “By a terrorist. The agenda is unclear, the demands vague, but she’s prepared to hold me here for at least two months. Twelve weeks or eighteen years, depending on how you look at it.”

“Nice way to talk about our future child,” said her boyfriend Crow.

And this literary reference also made me laugh. “I think of myself as Boo Radley, watching quietly, at the read to avenge.”

“You look more like Scout, trapped in her ham costume.”

Overall, The Girl in the Green Raincoat is an excellent novel with witty dialogue, fantastic characters, and a thrilling plot.

About Laura Lippman
Laura Lippman grew up in Baltimore and returned to her hometown in 1989 to work as a journalist. After writing seven books while still a full-time reporter, she left the Baltimore Sun to focus on fiction. The author of two New York Times bestsellers, What the Dead Know and Another Thing to Fall, she has won numerous awards for her work, including the Edgar, Quill, Anthony, Nero Wolfe, Agatha, Gumshoe, Barry, and Macavity.

To learn more about Laura’s work, visit her website or connect with her on Facebook.

This review is part of the TLC Book Tours.

For more reviews of this novel, please check out the rest of the tour stops:

Thursday, January 20th: Life In Review
Friday, January 21st: A Fanatic’s Book Blog
Monday, January 24th: Kelly’s Lucky You!
Tuesday, January 25th: In the Next Room
Wednesday, January 26th: Book Reviews by Molly
Thursday, January 27th: Books Are Like Candy Corn
Monday, January 31st: Books Like Breathing
Tuesday, February 1st: Good Girl Gone Redneck
Wednesday, February 2nd: Life in the Thumb
Thursday, February 3rd: Kahakai Kitchen

Book Source: Review Copy from Harper Collins Publishers. Thank-you!

Laura’s Top Ten Books of 2010

I read a lot of good books in 2010. I like to call 2010 the year that disappeared. With my horrific morning sickness at the beginning of the year, the birth of Penelope Rose on October 15th, and having a baby to nurse along with a 4 & 2 year old, I haven’t had as much time to socialize as I usually do. I did have a lot more time to read instead of sleeping!

Overall I read 95 books in 2010 and listened to 9 audiobooks. My number of books was up for the before stated reasons, but my number of audiobooks was down. I was in a number of challenges this year including The All About the Brontes Challenge, The Classics Challenge, The Stephanie Plum Reading Challenge, and the Everything Austen Challenge II. I was also in two book clubs, my Kewaunee Library Book Club and FLICKS Book and Movie Club.

I read a variety of books through the year, but I didn’t read as much non-fiction or sci-fi as I would usually like too. This is probably because between reading advance review copies of books, books for challenges, and books for my book clubs, I didn’t have much time to read personal picks. I need to work on this.

My top ten books are my favorite ten books that I read this year. They were not necessary published in the year 2010 and do not include books I read and enjoyed for a second, third, or fourth time (such as Pride and Prejudice, Outlander, Child of the Northern Spring) as it is obvious that I love those novels. If you are interested, check out my top 10 from 2009, 2008 and 2007.

Without further ado, my top ten favorite books of 2010 (in no particular order):

1. Room by Emma Donoghue – Room was a horrifying and heart-warming tale rolled into one told through a very unique prospective, that of a five-year old child. Jack has lived in a small room trapped with his abducted mother throughout his five-year life. The room encompasses his life, but things are about to change as Ma plans their escape. I literally couldn’t put this book down!
2. The Millennium Trilogy by Stieg Larsson – I know I’m cheating here by counting a trilogy as one selection, but I loved the entire trilogy and read it this year. Larsson weaves a unique tale set in Sweden, with a very unique heroine, Lisbeth Salander. Hero Mikael Bloomberg is a crusader who stops at nothing to get the story for his Millennium magazine and to right wrongs even if it means bringing down the Swedish government.
3. The Hunger Games Trilogy by Suzanne Collins – I loved this young adult trilogy set in a post-apoplectic world. The world has ended as we know it and the U.S. has been divided into thirteen districts. The districts are controlled by the capital and are kept under strict control. Each year each district is required to send two children to compete in the televised “Hunger Games.” There can only be one winner left alive at the end of the games. Katniss Everdeen is trying to keep her sister and mother alive in District 12 when her sister is chosen for the games. Katniss steps in to save her and her life is forever changed.
4. The Greatest Knight and The Scarlet Lion by Elizabeth Chadwick – These two novels are among the best historical fiction novels that I have ever read. I love the hero William Marshal. His story is a riveting tale that I had never read about before. Chadwick is a master storyteller that is vividly able to bring the past alive. I look forward to reading more of her novels!
5. The Book Thief by Markus Zusak – This book is uniquely narrated by death during WWII and tells the story of one girl and her struggle to survive during WWII in Germany. The German people not painted as only evil, but rather shades of gray.
6. Cleopatra’s Daughter by Michelle Moran – I honestly didn’t know that Cleopatra even had a daughter! Moran’s novel is an intriguing look at the life of the famed Queen’s children after her death.
7. A Reliable Wife by Robert Goolrich – A stark fascinating novel set in the depths of winter in Wisconsin. A mail order bride has arrived, but is she all that she seems to be? Lovers of gothic tales such as those written by the Brontes or Daphne Du Maurier will love this novel.
8. The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas – Although it has been almost two hundred years since this novel was written, it is still an action packed novel that kept me up in the night trying to find out what happened next. It is the ultimate novel of revenge.
9. The Season of Second Chances by Diane Meier – I loved this book. It was a unique story with a unique heroine, Joy Harkness, that has moved to a small town into a large Victorian mansion that needs a lot of fixing up. The characters are wonderfully drawn and the writing is superb.
10. Life of Pi by Yann Martel – Why do we believe? This tale of a boy and a tiger on the high seas was thought-provoking.

Books that I love tend to keep me thinking about them late into the night. I read a lot of good books this year and had a hard time narrowing them down. Special honorary shout-outs go to Spoken from the Heart by Laura Bush, Alone by Richard Logan and Tere Duperrault Fassbender, The Brave by Nicholas Evans, By Fire, By Water by Mitchell James Kaplan, and The Polski Affair by Leon H. Gilden. Also I have a special mention of Black Hills by Dan Simmons. This book had some of the best and most memorable scenes in fiction that I read (or listened to in this case) this year, but was brought down overall by some scenes that should have been cut (Brooklyn Bridge) and a too frisky General Custer.

Did you enjoy any of these novels? What were your favorite books in 2010?

The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy by Mary Lydon Simonsen

Have you ever wondered about Mr. Darcy’s side of the story in Pride and Prejudice? I know I like to think about Mr. Darcy! The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy chronicles Mr. Darcy’s love for Elizabeth Bennet and how his sister Georgiana and cousin Anne had to work their magic at times to get Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth together.

The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy mostly takes place between Mr. Darcy’s ill-fated proposal at Rosings to just after the marriage of Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth. This story is unique in that we get to find out what happened on Mr. Darcy’s side, and it also fills in the missing gaps on the Bennets' side.

The other unique aspect is that Anne de Bourgh is no longer the non-talkative invalid of Pride and Prejudice; she is a heroine with weak lungs who gives her all to ensure that her beloved cousin Fitzwilliam Darcy will have a happy ending. Unlike in P&P, she actually befriends Elizabeth and they become correspondents. She uses this opportunity to convince Elizabeth of Darcy’s goodness and also to make sure the timing of her holiday with find Mr. Darcy at home at Pemberley.

Georgiana has also changed in this version of the classic tale. She is no longer a shy wallflower, but is a budding author whose imagination takes flight at anything hinting of gothic mystery or of romance. Her curiosity of her brother’s secret love for Elizabeth leads her to help her cousin Anne to do anything she can to bring the two together.

The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy was a very well-written and enjoyable tale. It had great witty dialogue that made me laugh out loud a few times. Unlike some other Mr. Darcy books that just paraphrase Pride and Prejudice, The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy is a fully realized tale of its own that was very intriguing. Author Mary Lydon Simonsen took the original story and expanded on it, creating new intriguing characters, and developing other minor characters into riveting new characters themselves. I especially liked the expanded Bingley clan and older brother George. I also loved the humorous turn of events after Lydia elopes with Wickham.

Overall, The Perfect Bride for Mr. Darcy is the perfect book for all lovers of Pride and Prejudice to fill in the behind the scenes details of how our favorite two lovers were finally able to get together!

Author Mary Lydon Simonsen will be a guest on Laura’s Reviews this upcoming Thursday so stay tuned!

Book Source: Advance Review Copy from Sourcebooks. Thank-you!

The Winners of The Heir by Grace Burrowes

The two lucky winners of The Heir by Grace Burrowes are Nathalie of Book Eternity and Katherine. Congrats to you both!!

Winners were chosen using a monte carlo simulation in excel to generate random numbers. My computer doesn't seem to like random.org lately and I'm an engineer so excel is my best friend.

Both winners were notified via email and have until this Friday, January 21st, to send me their mailing addresses. If I don't hear from this by that time, I will draw new winners.

Thank-you to Danielle at Sourcebooks for allowing me to host this great giveaway. Thank-you to all who read this blog and entered the giveaway!

I still have one great giveaway for an audiobook copy of Cleopatra on the sidebar. Stay tuned this week for another new giveaway!

The Winners of An Object of Beauty by Steve Martin Audiobook

The two lucky winners of audiobook copies of An Object of Beauty by Steve Martin are katklaw777 and DarcyO. Congratulations!! The two winners were chosen using a Monte Carlo simulation to generate random numbers in excel (random.org is not working on my computer again!).

I have emailed the winners and they have until this Friday, January 21st, to send me their mailing address. Otherwise, new winners will be drawn.

Thank-you to Anna from Hachette Book Group for allowing me to host this great giveaway. I look forward to reviewing the book myself!

Sad you didn't win? There is still an ongoing giveaway for the audiobook version of Cleopatra on my sidebar and stay tuned this week for another great giveaway!

Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen

I was evil this month for my FLICKS Book and Movie club and chose two books for my fellow members to read. In my defense, I don’t get to chose again until next fall and One for the Money and Water for Elephants were both books I wanted to chose and both the movie versions of them come out before my next turn. Since we like to go to movies together, I thought I’d pick these both to see if they would be movies that my club would like to see together.

Jacob Jankowski is a ninety-three year old retired veterinarian that lives in assisted living. A circus comes to town and sets up across the street from the assisted living. The excitement of the circus among the residents brings back memories to Jacob of the time that he worked for the circus in his youth.

Jacob’s parents were killed in a car accident a week before he was due to graduate from Cornell with his veterinary degree. The plan had been for Jacob to return home after graduation and join his father’s practice. After his parents’ death, Jacob learns they had mortgaged their home to the hilt in order to send him to school. It is the 1930’s and times were tough. Jacob is in turmoil and is not sure what to do with his life. On a whim, he jumps on a train only to discover it is a circus train.

The circus manager, Big Al, is happy to discover he is a Cornell trained vet and Jacob is on the show. Jacob learns the ropes of the circus and discovers that the people and animals are not treated well. He also meets the beautiful Marlena and her moody husband, August. Big Al buys an elephant for the circus named Rosie that is unable to perform. This puts the circus in financial difficulties. Will Rosie save the circus? Will Jacob and Marlena find a way to be together?

It has been a few years since I first read Water for Elephants. I remembered the basic story, but I really enjoyed reading it again for the second time and seeing all of the details I missed. Being a few years older, I also had a different prospective on the “old man” parts of the book. The first time around I was bored by them, but this time around, they were some of my favorite parts. I think having my Great-Grandma in assisted living and then passing away made me think more about what it would be like to be an old person at the end of your life living in assisted living.

My favorite quote in the book is, “When you’re five, you know your age down to the month. Even in your twenties you know how old you are. I’m twenty-three, you say, or maybe twenty-seven. But then in your thirties something strange starts to happen. It’s a mere hiccup at first, an instant of hesitation. How old are you? Oh, I’m – you start confidently, but then you stop. You were going to say thirty-three, but you’re not. You’re thirty-five. And then you’re bothered, because you wonder if this is the beginning of the end. It is, of course, but it’s decades before you admit it.”

This happened to me. I made fun of my husband for not remembering how old he is (he’s two years older than me), but then once I hit thirty, the same thing started to happen to me. I have to think about how old I am when people ask me. I often think I’m my husband’s age and then am relieved to realize I’m two years younger!

I also enjoy the great historic detail on the workings of a traveling train circus in the 1930’s. I found them to be fascinating and something new that I had never read about before. I especially liked the historic pictures at the beginning of each chapter. My book club also enjoyed this aspect of the novel. I think we need to take a road trip to The Circus World Museum in Baraboo, WI. I’ve never been there before (I grew up in Michigan).

One book club member did not like this book due to the animal cruelty. There are scenes of animal cruelty that were very disturbing. Luckily Jacob didn’t see them first hand, although he heard them and saw the after effects. Author Sara Gruen gives the historic basis of some of this cruelty in her author’s note in the back. Sadly the real story was worse than the fictional story.

I myself was disturbed by the cruelty to the circus workers. The practice of “redlighting” workers by throwing them off the train when the circus was in hard financial straits is more than a little disturbing. I actually had to do a quick research online to see if it was true that such things happened after I finished the book and unfortunately, it looks like it did.
I am looking forward to the movie. What do you think of the casting of Robert Pattinson and Reese Witherspoon in these roles?

Overall, I enjoyed this book all over again for the second time. It is a great story love story, a great historical fiction story of circuses in the 1930’s, a great story of life in your 90’s, and a great mystery (whodunit from the prologue). Water for Elephants was first recommended to me by a member of my book club in Milwaukee and was now passed on by me to my current book club. It is my first book for the Historical Fiction Challenge 2011.

Book Source: My brother-in-law and sister-in-law gave it to me for Christmas a few years ago.

In Defense of Stephanie Plum

I picked One for the Money for my FLICKS Book and Movie Club pick this month as I think the Stephanie Plum series is a light and funny set of books, and more importantly, there is a movie version coming out of One for the Money this summer and since this club likes to get together and go to a movie, I thought this would be a good choice. This particular book club also loves a good love triangle, and what could be better than Stephanie, Ranger, and Joe?

Well, it had been awhile since I had read this book and I had forgotten that the love triangle does not get more developed until later in the series. The Ranger I know and love was only fleetingly shown. I also love Lula and Grandma Mazur, but they only have brief appearances.

One for the Money is a good set-up book for the series in its introduction of Stephanie Plum and her new career as a bounty hunter. Stephanie is a lingerie buyer that has been out of a job for six months. She’s out of money and goes to her cousin Vinnie for a job in his bail bondsmen office as a file clerk. The file clerk position has been filled, so Stephanie instead takes the information on Joe Morelli, a former high school love turn nemesis after he wrote about their romantic encounter on the walls of a bathroom. Morelli is a cop accused of murdering an unarmed man and is on the run. Stephanie wants the large sum (ten grand) that she will get for turning him in to turn her life back around. She learns the ropes from the ultimate man of mystery, Ranger, and has some scary encounters with deranged boxer Benito Ramirez. Will Stephanie capture Morelli?

I must admit, I love book club when a book can get people talking. And the best way to get people talking is if they don’t like a book. Often at book club, we tend to pick books that fall within our comfort zone. I like to read books that I normally wouldn’t pick up and learn about new authors or a new genre that I haven’t read before. I think that book clubs are a perfect opportunity for this. I sometimes try to pick books that are different from the normal reading habits of my book club just for this reason.

While most members of the book club liked One for the Money, one member did not. She hated Stephanie Plum, the tone of the book, and couldn’t finish it. She thought it was just a set up for a movie with great lines, but not realistic. This assessment of the book got me thinking about it and about Stephanie Plum, which is exactly what I like a book club to do.

I realized I have a totally different view of Stephanie Plum. I like Stephanie because she is different from most heroines of novels. She is not a perfect person on a pedestal waiting for a white knight to rescue her. She doesn’t live in a huge mansion with a rich family. She is a flawed person that has an addiction to food, crazy relatives, and is majorly indecisive. She has problems with her bills and is not the world’s best bounty hunter. But through it all Stephanie remains positive. She has brunt honesty about her short comings, family, and friends that I find refreshingly funny. I love the first person narrative structure of the book where you getting thoughts straight from Stephanie. I think that Stephanie is a great real heroine. While Stephanie may find herself in situations that I don’t, she reminds me of some of my friends and would be a fun person to have over for dinner!

My friend also didn’t like Morelli and thought he didn’t get much character development. Here I also must heckle my friend. You didn’t finish the book! Morelli is a man on the run so he is only fleetingly in the beginning of the book when Stephanie is on the look-out for him. They have more time together toward the end of the book and I thought the ending was pretty romantic myself . . . but Morelli is a man’s man and romance to him may be eating pizza and watching the game!

Overall though, while I harass my friend, I also want to thank her. I like when someone can truthfully admit to not liking a book, can create a good discussion, and can keep me thinking into the night why I do like my book!

After reading One of the Money again, I realized I liked the character additions and developments that happen throughout the series. I must admit though that I think the series peaked at somewhere like book seven or so. The newest books, while they make me laugh, there seems to be no new character development. I would really like the story to keep moving. Have Stephanie finally pick someone!

What do you think? Are you a fan of Stephanie or did you try to read about her and hated her? Please tell me your story! And what do you think of Katherine Heigl as Stephanie? I am not a fan of that casting.

On a side note, this book was written way before a movie was ever thought of. This book was originally published in 1994, which you can tell when they have “car phones” and a lack of cell phones at critical moments. It was funny to read about the lack of technology!

Book Source: I purchased this book at Target.